Trading in your old car when you’re ready for a new vehicle can significantly reduce the upfront cost and even offer potential tax benefits. Dealership trade-ins are often favored for their speed and convenience compared to private sales. However, understanding your current car’s worth is crucial to ensure you get a fair deal during negotiations.
This guide will walk you through the process of trading in a car, providing essential steps and valuable tips to maximize your trade-in value.
How Car Trade-Ins Work
When you trade in your car, the dealership assesses its value and offers you credit towards the purchase of a new or used vehicle from their inventory. This trade-in value effectively lowers the amount you need to finance with a new auto loan.
Opting for a dealership trade-in streamlines the process, getting you behind the wheel of your new car more quickly. While private sales might potentially yield a higher selling price, they typically require more time and effort. It’s also worth noting that businesses like CarMax offer an alternative: they will buy your car outright, even if you don’t plan to purchase a vehicle from them.
6 Key Steps to Trading In Your Car
1. Determine Your Car’s Trade-In Value
Before you step into a dealership, arm yourself with knowledge of your car’s trade-in value. Online car valuation tools are invaluable resources for this. By inputting your car’s year, make, model, mileage, and condition, you can get a reliable estimate of its worth. For a more detailed assessment of your car’s condition, the Kelley Blue Book (KBB) condition quiz is a helpful tool to refine your trade-in value estimation. It’s important to be realistic; KBB notes that only a small percentage of trade-in vehicles are considered to be in “excellent condition.”
Here are some widely recognized online guides for obtaining a free vehicle appraisal:
- Kelley Blue Book (KBB)
- Edmunds
- NADA Guides
If these guides provide varying values, using the highest estimate as a starting point for negotiation at the dealership is advisable. While aiming for at least the minimum trade-in value suggested by these guides is reasonable, be aware that dealerships often use the Black Book Value for appraisals, which might result in a lower offer than initially estimated.
Understanding the different values associated with your car is key in the trade-in process:
- Wholesale Price or Value: This is what dealers typically pay at auctions when acquiring used vehicles. It’s adjusted based on factors like vehicle condition, age, and KBB value, and it is usually the lowest value.
- Trade-In Value or Price: This is the offer a dealer will make for your car, based on industry guidelines, its condition, and local demand. Trade-in values are generally slightly less than wholesale prices.
- Private Sale Price or Value: Selling your car privately, perhaps through platforms like Craigslist, can often get you the highest return. However, this method requires more effort and time.
- Retail Price or Value: Also known as the Manufacturer’s Suggested Retail Price (MSRP), this is the dealership’s full asking price for a new car. Trading in your existing vehicle can often be used as leverage to negotiate a lower retail price on a new car.
2. Find Out Your Car Loan Payoff Amount
If you possess a clear car title, free of any liens, you’re well-prepared for the trade-in process. However, if you’re still paying off your car loan, it’s essential to contact your lender to determine the outstanding balance. Inquire about any potential prepayment penalties if you decide to pay off the loan early.
Trading in a car with an existing loan is common. The key factor is whether your car’s trade-in value is higher or lower than your loan balance. Here are the two possible scenarios:
- Positive Equity: If your car is worth more than what you owe, you have positive equity. The difference can be applied as a down payment on your new vehicle, reducing your loan amount and potentially your monthly payments. For example, if you owe $10,000 on a car valued at $15,000, the $5,000 difference can serve as your down payment.
- Negative Equity: If your car is worth less than your loan balance, you have negative equity (sometimes called being “upside down” on your loan). You’ll need to cover this difference, either with a cash down payment or by rolling the negative equity into your new car loan. For instance, if you owe $25,000 on a car worth $20,000, you could roll the $5,000 negative equity into your new loan. Be aware that this will increase your new loan amount, interest charges, and monthly payments.
3. Gather Essential Documents
Having all necessary documents ready will expedite the trade-in process. Here’s a checklist of what you’ll likely need:
- Car Title: This document proves your ownership of the vehicle and authorizes you to transfer ownership to the dealership. If you can’t locate your title, contact your lender or your local Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to inquire about a replacement. Note that replacement titles can take time to process, potentially delaying your trade-in.
- Car Registration: Your car registration also serves as proof of ownership, regardless of whether you have an outstanding loan.
- Loan Information: If you have a car loan, bring details about your lender, your account number, and the remaining balance. If you intend to finance your new car through the dealership, ask about required car loan documents, such as proof of income, residency, and insurance.
- Maintenance Records: Documents showcasing regular maintenance and care can strengthen your negotiation position, potentially justifying a higher trade-in value.
In most states, trading in a car without a title is legally problematic because the title contains crucial vehicle information, including the Vehicle Identification Number (VIN), make, model, and owner details. Without it, dealerships cannot legally verify your ownership, which can significantly delay or halt the trade-in.
While exceptions may exist in certain states or for very old vehicles, it’s best to confirm local regulations and dealership policies. If you’re missing your title, obtaining a replacement from the DMV is generally necessary for a smooth trade-in.
4. Shop Around for Multiple Trade-In Quotes
Trade-in offers can vary significantly between dealerships. Factors influencing these offers include the dealership’s current inventory, the condition of your car, and their confidence in reselling it. To strengthen your negotiation position, it’s wise to obtain multiple written trade-in quotes from different dealerships. Getting pre-approved for a car loan beforehand can also give you leverage. Always be mindful of potential hidden dealer fees.
Consider these avenues when seeking trade-in offers:
- Dealerships of Different Brands: A dealership specializing in a different brand than your car might be more eager to acquire your vehicle to diversify their used car selection. For example, a Nissan dealer might offer a more attractive price for your Ford than a Ford dealer who already has many Fords in stock.
- Used Car Dealerships: Dedicated used car dealerships like CarMax often provide free, no-obligation trade-in appraisals, offering a quick way to get a written offer.
- Online Car Buying Services: Explore online platforms that buy used cars. You can either sell your car directly through these services or use their written offers to negotiate a better trade-in price at local dealerships. KBB Instant Cash Offer is a well-known option to consider.
5. Skillfully Negotiate Trade-In Offers
Dealerships typically start with lower trade-in offers, expecting negotiation. Don’t accept offers below the minimum value suggested by online guides. If a dealer is unwilling to meet this minimum, be prepared to explore other dealerships.
Keep these negotiation points in mind:
- Verify the Dealer’s Appraisal Guide: If a dealer disputes your trade-in value, inquire about the industry guide they are using. Check the data on your smartphone to ensure transparency and fairness in their appraisal.
- Ask the Dealer to Cover Negative Equity: If you have negative equity, it’s worth asking the dealer to cover the outstanding balance, even if it exceeds the car’s value. While it may not always be successful, asking is always worthwhile.
- Confirm the New Car Price: Some dealers may try to compensate for a higher trade-in value by inflating the price of the new vehicle. Carefully review the detailed cost breakdown of the new car before finalizing any agreements.
6. Review and Finalize the Trade-In Agreement
Once you and the dealer reach an agreement on the trade-in value, carefully review all paperwork before signing. Ensure you fully understand the agreed-upon trade-in value and the final price of the new vehicle. Remember that car purchases are typically final once you sign the contract. If you are financing the new car, research different types of auto loans beforehand to secure the best terms and rates for your budget and needs.
Pros and Cons of Trading In Your Car
Advantages
- Speed and Convenience: Dealerships manage the entire trade-in process efficiently, from appraisal to title transfer.
- No Need to Prepare Your Car for Sale: You don’t need to worry about cleaning, detailing, or making minor repairs – the dealership handles that.
- Potential Sales Tax Savings: In many states, the trade-in value of your old car can reduce the taxable price of your new car, resulting in sales tax savings.
- Down Payment Alternative: Positive equity from your trade-in can serve as a down payment on your new vehicle, reducing your out-of-pocket expenses.
Disadvantages
- Potentially Lower Value: Trading in usually yields less money than selling privately.
- Limited Options If Deal Falls Through: If the trade-in offer is unacceptable, you might need to find a different car at another dealership, potentially disrupting your purchase plans.
- Final Sale Agreement: Once you sign the trade-in agreement, the dealership legally owns your car, even if financing for your new vehicle later falls through due to credit or financial issues.
Is Trading In Your Car the Right Choice?
Trading in your car offers numerous advantages, particularly convenience and speed. It simplifies the process compared to private sales, as dealerships handle appraisals, repairs, and paperwork. Private sales require time for advertising, scheduling test drives with potential buyers, and dealing with DMV processes.
A favorable trade-in offer can cover your existing loan balance and reduce the overall cost of your new car.
However, if you have significant negative equity on your current car and are primarily seeking to lower your monthly payments, exploring car refinancing might be a more beneficial option than trading in.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I trade in a car if I still owe money on it?
Yes, in most cases, dealerships accept financed cars as trade-ins. However, trading in doesn’t eliminate your existing car loan. You’ll still need to pay off the remaining balance, either through the trade-in value or by rolling it into your new auto loan. If your car’s trade-in value exceeds your loan balance, the dealership will typically handle paying off your existing loan. Contact the dealership in advance to discuss trading in a car that isn’t fully paid off.
Do I need to do anything to prepare my car for trade-in?
While extensive preparation isn’t required for a used car trade-in, a few simple steps can potentially enhance its perceived value. Consider basic cleaning, like a car wash and interior vacuuming. Ensuring you have a clean title without outstanding issues is also helpful.
What if I don’t like the trade-in offer?
Never feel pressured to accept the first offer. Negotiate with the dealer. If they are unwilling to budge, seek offers from other dealerships or online car-buying platforms like Carvana or CarMax. Alternatively, consider selling your car privately for potentially higher returns, but be prepared for the added time and effort involved in advertising, showing the car, and dealing with potential buyers and safety considerations. Be cautious of unrealistically high offers, as they could be scams.
Compare Auto Loans in Minutes
