Are you wondering if it’s possible to return a financed car to the dealership? It’s a common question, and unfortunately, the answer isn’t always straightforward. While there are instances where returning a financed vehicle might be an option, they are not the norm. In many cases, returning a car after you’ve signed the financing paperwork can be challenging.
To help clarify this issue, we’ll explore the situations where returning a financed car could be possible and, conversely, when it’s unlikely. Furthermore, we’ll discuss alternative solutions if returning your car isn’t feasible. Understanding your options is crucial when you’re facing this situation.
When Is Returning a Financed Car Possible?
While it’s generally uncommon to return a car once the purchase is finalized, there are specific circumstances where it may be an option. These situations are exceptions rather than the rule, but it’s important to know about them. Here are four scenarios where returning a financed car might be possible:
1. Dealer Return Policy
Some dealerships offer a return policy, sometimes advertised as a “money-back guarantee,” as a customer incentive. Companies like Carvana and CarMax are known for such policies, offering return windows of 7 and 10 days respectively.
If your dealership has a return policy, you may be able to return the car, provided you adhere to the policy’s timeframe and conditions. However, carefully review the fine print. Return policies often come with stipulations. For example, the dealership might refuse a return if the vehicle has been damaged or if there are additional liens on it besides the auto loan. Always clarify the specifics of the return policy before relying on it.
2. Lemon Laws
Both federal and state “lemon laws” are in place to protect consumers who purchase vehicles with significant defects that occur under warranty. These laws ensure that if a manufacturer cannot fix a substantial issue after a reasonable number of attempts during the warranty period, they must offer a refund or replace the vehicle.
If you believe you’ve purchased a lemon, the first step is to contact your state’s Office of the Attorney General. As the state’s chief legal officer, the Attorney General typically handles lemon law claims and can guide you to the appropriate resources for filing your claim. Lemon laws vary by state, so understanding your local regulations is essential if you suspect your car qualifies as a lemon.
3. Bait-and-Switch Fraud
The car buying process can sometimes be rushed, and in the past, some dealerships have exploited this to engage in bait-and-switch tactics. This involves offering one vehicle or financing deal initially, only to change the terms or vehicle at the last minute, often to the consumer’s financial disadvantage.
Fortunately, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has introduced the CARS Rule to combat auto retail scams. This rule prohibits dealerships from misrepresenting key aspects of a sale and mandates transparency regarding financing terms, optional features, and add-ons.
If you suspect you’ve been a victim of dealer fraud, contact the FTC’s Fraud division. Reporting your experience to the FTC can help them investigate and potentially take action against fraudulent dealerships. They can also provide guidance on the best course of action and may involve law enforcement if necessary.
4. Military Deployment (Servicemembers Civil Relief Act – SCRA)
The Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA) offers certain protections to active-duty military personnel, including the possibility of early vehicle lease termination without penalties or early termination fees under specific conditions.
This protection applies to those called to active duty, those receiving Permanent Change of Station orders internationally, or those deployed for 180 days or more. The specifics of the protection can depend on the duty station’s location and whether the lease was initiated before or during active duty.
It’s crucial to note that the SCRA provisions related to vehicle returns apply only to auto leases, not auto loans. If you are a servicemember facing deployment and have a financed car (loan), this particular provision will not apply, although other protections under SCRA might be relevant to your broader financial situation.
When Is Returning a Financed Car Unlikely?
Now, let’s consider common scenarios where you might want to return your vehicle, but a return is unlikely to be accepted by the dealership. Understanding these situations can help manage expectations.
1. Buyer’s Remorse
Buyer’s remorse is a common feeling after a large purchase. Perhaps you’ve changed your mind about the car’s color, or you’ve realized another type of vehicle would better suit your needs. However, in most cases, buyer’s remorse is not a valid reason to return a financed car once the deal is complete.
Dealerships are generally not legally required to offer a grace period for returns due to buyer’s remorse. Unless a dealer specifically advertises a return policy as part of their customer service, they are unlikely to accept a return simply because you’ve changed your mind. This underscores the importance of careful consideration and research before finalizing a car purchase.
2. Inability to Afford Payments
Financial circumstances can change unexpectedly. You might find that your new car payments are more than you budgeted for, or your financial situation may have shifted due to job loss or other unforeseen events. Unfortunately, being unable to afford your car payments is typically not considered a valid reason to return the vehicle to the dealership.
Dealerships are in the business of selling cars and providing financing; they are not typically equipped to handle returns based on a customer’s changed financial capacity. If you’re facing difficulty making payments, it’s important to explore other options like payment assistance programs or auto loan refinancing, which we’ll discuss next.
Alternatives to Returning Your Financed Car
Since returning a financed car can be difficult, it’s helpful to know about alternative solutions. Each option has its own advantages and disadvantages, which should be carefully considered based on your individual circumstances.
| Alternative Method | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Discuss Hardship Assistance with Lender | Can provide temporary relief during financial difficulties like job loss. | Not all lenders offer these options, and you still owe the full loan amount. Loan terms might change, potentially extending the repayment period. |
| Refinance Your Car Loan | Allows you to keep your car and potentially improve your financial situation by lowering monthly payments or interest rates. Protects your credit score compared to more drastic measures. | May involve upfront fees. You still owe the original loan amount, and extending the loan term means paying more interest over time. |
| Trade In Your Car | Lets you switch to a different vehicle that might be more suitable or affordable. Reduces the amount you owe to the dealership if the trade-in value is applied to a new purchase. | Depreciation can mean your car’s trade-in value is less than your loan balance, creating negative equity. You may still owe money on the traded-in car and take on new debt. |
| Sell Your Car | Allows you to pay off your loan directly without dealership involvement. You control the selling process and potential sale price. | You will no longer have a car after the sale. Depreciation may result in owing more on the loan than the car sells for, requiring you to pay the difference out-of-pocket. |
| Voluntary Repossession | Can be a last resort to avoid lender-initiated repossession. May be seen slightly less negatively than a full repossession on your credit report. | Still significantly damages your credit score, making it harder to borrow money in the future. You lose the car and may still owe the deficiency balance if the car sale doesn’t cover the loan. |
Car-Buying Tips: 6 Strategies to Help Avoid Car Return Scenarios
Prevention is better than cure. Avoiding the need to return a car in the first place is ideal. Here are some car-buying tips to increase your satisfaction with your purchase long-term:
- Thorough Research: Before you even step into a dealership, research different car models, read reviews, and compare features. Understand what you need and what you want in a vehicle.
- Test Drive Extensively: Don’t just drive around the block. Take an extended test drive in conditions that mimic your daily driving. Pay attention to comfort, handling, and features.
- Financial Planning: Determine your budget before car shopping. Get pre-approved for a loan to understand interest rates and monthly payments you qualify for. Don’t stretch your budget too thin.
- Inspect Carefully: Before signing anything, thoroughly inspect the car, both inside and out. If buying used, consider a pre-purchase inspection by an independent mechanic.
- Understand the Paperwork: Read every document carefully before signing. Don’t rush through the financing paperwork. Ask questions about anything you don’t understand.
- Consider a Return Policy: If available, opt for a dealership with a reasonable return policy, even if it adds slightly to the cost. This can provide peace of mind.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will returning a car hurt my credit score?
Whether returning a car impacts your credit score depends on the method. Returning a car under a dealer’s return policy, within the specified window, should not affect your credit. However, options like voluntary repossession will negatively impact your credit score.
Can I trade in a financed car that I’m still paying off?
Yes, it’s possible to trade in a financed car even if you haven’t finished paying off the loan. However, be aware that if your car’s trade-in value is less than your outstanding loan balance (due to depreciation), you’ll still owe the difference (negative equity). This amount is often rolled into the new car loan, increasing your overall debt.
Compare Auto Loans in Minutes
