The car rental industry has faced turbulent times, and it’s not just about vehicle depreciation. Back in November 2016, even established giants like Hertz experienced a sharp decline in shares due to slashed profit forecasts. While they pointed fingers at depreciation, the real issue might be staring them right in the face: the evolving preferences of travelers who are increasingly turning to ride-sharing services like Lyft and Uber.
For frequent travelers, the appeal of ride-sharing is undeniable. Imagine bypassing long queues at rental counters, confusing paperwork, and unexpected surcharges. Services like Lyft offer a seamless experience – a driver at your service, navigating unfamiliar city streets, all accessible through a user-friendly app. This shift in consumer behavior was highlighted in a New York Times column by Ron Lieber, who also admitted to opting for ride-sharing over traditional car rentals while traveling. The ease of summoning and paying for a ride with Lyft or Uber contrasts sharply with the often cumbersome and unpleasant experience associated with renting a car.
Reports of negative experiences with rental car companies are widespread. Payless Car Rental, for instance, has been criticized for stringent refueling policies and dubious insurance charges. However, negative experiences aren’t limited to just one company. Consider these common rental car nightmares reported by travelers:
- Arriving at the rental facility after an online reservation, only to be told no cars are available. Securing a vehicle only after trekking to another location, with no apologies or compensation.
- Being given a smoke-filled car with a casual shrug from the staff – “Someone must have smoked in it when they weren’t supposed to.” Again, no resolution or alternative offered.
- Enduring lengthy waits for shuttles, followed by more waiting in line at the rental counter, only to be left to inspect the car for damage in the dark with just a form and no pen.
- Being instructed to refuel within a mile of the rental location, assured of nearby stations, only to find them closed at an early hour.
Adding to these woes are the confusing car class categories, perplexing refueling options, and high-pressure sales tactics for insurance waivers. It’s no wonder that many now prefer to simply open their Lyft app.
Think about your last car rental experience. What stands out? It’s often the interaction at the rental counter – the customer service, the ease of the process, whether the promised car was available, and the stress of the paperwork. Negative experiences not only sour the trip but also create lasting negative impressions of the rental car brand. These cumulative negative memories erode the long-term value of rental car companies as a whole. This customer experience aspect is crucial for any brand aiming for longevity, as explored in “The Intuitive Customer: 7 Imperatives for Moving Your Customer Experience to the Next Level” by Colin Shaw and Professor Ryan Hamilton.
As Lyft and Uber expand their reach and services, including advance reservations, traditional car rental companies risk losing further ground if they fail to prioritize customer needs and improve their service experience. Tools like customer mirrors and behavioral journey mapping can help understand customer sentiments and design better experiences.
Unfortunately, immediate, sweeping changes from major rental car companies seem unlikely. As noted by Mr. Lieber, giants like Hertz and Avis even declined to comment on the issues raised.
Considering Lyft for your transportation needs? While Lyft doesn’t operate in the traditional “car rental” model where you pick up a car and drive it yourself for an extended period, it effectively serves as a powerful alternative to renting a car, especially for travelers within cities. The convenience, app-based accessibility, and often superior customer experience make services like Lyft a compelling option to consider before automatically resorting to a traditional car rental.
Would you prefer using a ride-sharing service like Lyft or renting a car? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
Explore how to enhance Customer Experience and prevent customer attrition – discover Beyond Philosophy’s range of training programs.
