The chilling case of Carly Gregg, a teenager convicted of murdering her mother, Ashley Smylie, has gripped the nation. The question on many minds is, Why Did Carly Gregg Shoot Her Mom? This article delves into the details of the tragic event, exploring the factors that led to this devastating crime and the subsequent trial that resulted in Gregg’s life sentence.
Carly Gregg’s case emerged from a horrific incident in Brandon, Mississippi, where the then 14-year-old fatally shot her mother in their family home. The events unfolded in March and culminated in a dramatic trial in September, bringing to light not only the gruesome act but also the complex mental state of the young perpetrator. Expert testimony revealed a troubled teenager grappling with severe mental health issues, painting a picture far more nuanced than a simple act of teenage rebellion.
According to court testimony, prior to the fatal shooting, Carly Gregg was under the care of a child psychiatrist, Dr. Andrew Clark. He testified during her trial, detailing her struggles with depression and the side effects of prescribed medication that left her feeling emotionally numb. Crucially, Dr. Clark revealed that Gregg reported hearing voices, a symptom that had been intensifying in the period leading up to the tragic day. Furthermore, her history of self-harm underscored a deeper, ongoing mental health crisis.
The prosecution’s case laid out a sequence of events that painted a disturbing picture. They stated that Carly Gregg used her mother’s own firearm to commit the murder within their Brandon residence. Following the act, instead of seeking help, Gregg allegedly called a friend and invited them over to witness the aftermath, reportedly asking, “Are you squeamish around dead bodies?” before showing her friend her deceased mother. Adding another layer of alleged premeditation, prosecutors claimed Gregg then lay in wait, intending to ambush and kill her stepfather, Heath Smylie, upon his return home. Gregg fled the scene but was apprehended shortly after near the house.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(744×304:746×306)/ashley-smylie-carly-madison-gregg-091724-1-bb21c39b73d44ff3af00fb69aa0abb35.jpg)
Testimony from Dr. Clark also shed light on the events of the day of the shooting. He described Gregg as being “grumpy and irritable” and struggling with focus at Northwest Rankin High School, where tragically, her mother, Ashley Smylie, was a math teacher. Gregg reportedly claimed a memory lapse on that day, after letting the family dog out. The courtroom heard that after returning home with her mother, Gregg went directly to her parents’ bedroom, retrieved a .357 Magnum pistol from under their mattress, concealed it, and then confronted her mother in her own bedroom. There, she fatally shot Ashley Smylie three times.
A potential trigger for the outburst was revealed in court. Prosecutor Kathryn White Newman stated that moments before the shooting, Ashley Smylie was searching Carly’s bedroom for vape pens. Dr. Clark elaborated on this point, explaining that “her mother finds out she’s smoking marijuana,” which for Carly, who deeply valued her mother’s approval, was perceived as “a crisis.” This discovery of marijuana use, coupled with Gregg’s fragile mental state, may have been a significant factor in the escalation to violence.
Dr. Clark further described Carly’s relationship with her mother as “close, yet complicated,” and noted a strong bond with her stepfather. In contrast, her relationship with her biological father was described as problematic, potentially contributing to her overall mental instability. Gregg’s own journal and sketchbook entries, cited by Dr. Clark, revealed her anxieties about her mental health, indicating an internal awareness of her struggles.
Ultimately, despite the defense’s efforts to highlight Gregg’s mental state, a Rankin County jury found her guilty on all charges: first-degree murder, attempted murder, and evidence tampering. Carly Gregg was sentenced to life in prison, marking a somber conclusion to a case that underscores the critical intersection of mental health and violent crime. While the question of why Carly Gregg shot her mom may never be fully answered, the trial revealed a confluence of mental health issues, a troubled family dynamic, and a potential immediate trigger that culminated in an unspeakable tragedy.
Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up for PEOPLE’s free True Crime newsletter for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases.
